eBusiness Marketing

Introduction:

So far we have discussed the role of e-Business in shaping the business model of organizations and creating an e-Business Infrastructure. Our focus was on the value proposition of e-Business or, in other words, the “promise” and the “delivery” against that promise which is enabled by the technology infrastructure.

This week we will introduce and discuss the decisions surrounding e-Business Marketing:

  • Customer: How do we put the customer at the center of an organization?
  • Customer Service: How do we ensure sustained customer loyalty?
  • Marketing mix: What are some marketing decisions? How do they drive e-Business success or failure?
  • Market Research: What is our market? Who is our customer? What do they want?
  • Personalization: How do we use the internet to create a market segment of “one” customer? Does that give us a competitive advantage?

The big picture:

e-Business has produced some spectacular winners such as e-Bay. However, there have been many more failures such as ChipShot.com. What is more interesting is a category of companies that we cannot put in either category, such as Amazon.com - it has been a spectacular success in generating clicks and revenues but has yet to turn a profit.

  • What contributed the success of the former and the failure of the latter?
  • What is the reason behind Amazon.com’s spectacular success in attracting customers? What is keeping it from profitability?

There are many known reasons for the failures. As we have already discussed, some of the answers are in the business model, some others in timing and the rest are strewn around in strategy, processes, technology and organization. For example, Amazon.com capitalized on the first mover advantage to gain an enviable online market share. However, did it pay too much to create a market segment? In other words, were its customer acquisition costs in line with its “brick” competitors? Can it capitalize on this investment?

Successful companies have all got one thing in common – they focus on the customer.

Marketing Strategies:

Customer affects all aspects of a business - from model and strategy to service and revenue to cost. Consequently, everything should be built with the customer in mind i.e. to succeed one must put the customer at the center of every decision.

  • Who is our customer?
  • What do they need? What do they want?
  • What are their likes and dislikes?
  • How can I reach them?
  • How can I keep them?

These questions can make or break an organization. New ventures have grasped this message, or parts of it, very well. It is the “old economy” companies that have taken some time to get there.

The following clients shall remain nameless for obvious reasons but they personify what is fundamentally wrong with “just do it” and keeping up with the “flavor of the month” as it relates to technology.

  • A client of mine spent millions developing Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT) capability and web service capability for its multi-million customers. They saved a dollar per customer and transaction. What a deal, we need a supercomputer to run the ROI on this one! There was only one problem. The customers were all retirees in their 60s, 70s and 80s. What do you think is the rate of adoption of the internet in this space? Can you imagine the number of service calls to handle the “has the money been deposited” question?
  • Another client spent millions developing a cutting edge wireless capability. Their trail blazing product was one of the first available on the handhelds such as Palm. Their pictures were on the cover of some very prestigious magazines. They got 800 hits a month on their website. And that was a good month! This client generated $0 from each hit as the transactions were predominantly inquiries. Even for each “real” transaction, they would have made pennies. The company offers retirement products such as 401(k)s. They do not have their own funds so they offer others’ funds!
    • How frequently does one trade one’s 401(k) accounts?
    • When was the last time that you had to change allocations from a train/plane/automobile?
    • And the real kicker, it is not the fee but the spread, stupid!

There are many more stories that one can tell. The idea is not to laugh at someone else’s mistakes (for every one of theirs, there are 10 of ours!) but to learn from them.

These examples illustrate the essence of marketing strategy, namely, matching your customer with the product, price, and distribution. Know thy customer. Know thy product. Know thy channel. Know thy value (price, promotion, packaging etc. establish a “fair” offering by providing an acceptable value for exchange!).

Could we have used promotions to encourage some of the customers to start using their Palm’s to manage their retirement savings?

Customers, as we all know, come in various shapes and sizes. Typically, a product cannot satisfy all the needs of all the customers all the time. Consequently, customer segmentation or dividing customers into groups of, almost, similar preferences or geography or some other criteria results in better marketing results. If we know what that segment prefers we can make a product to those requirements and the chances of adoption are better. Could you imagine how these results would improve if we could further refine these segments? Can you imagine trying to ascertain, record, and act on the preferences of this every enlarging portfolio of segments? Can you imagine mass producing a product to meet a million segments of one?

Mass customization, i.e. mass producing product(s) to suit a million segments of one each is perhaps the most powerful capability a company can have. Not only do customers love it, it saves a bundle on inventory costs. One of the most important capabilities the web has to offer is the ability to mass customize. What was lacking so far was the production and supply chain to match up the marketing and order taking capability. Many companies, including car manufacturers such as Toyota and Mercedes have made great strides in this area. On some models of Toyota, one can design and take delivery in less than a week!

Market Research

One of the biggest dilemmas facing a marketing manager in the internet space is how to “know thy customer”?

One could argue that since we are looking for customers who use the internet we should conduct research on the net. What if you are introducing a new service that would benefit by converting the “brick” customers to “click” ala Amazon.com? How would you get to that potential customer on the net?

The question becomes especially tricky if one is trying to ascertain the preference of customers as they relate to offering a product using “brick” or “click”. An online customer is likely to skew the balance towards the internet and an offline one the other way. Using one medium is likely to result in a miscalculation.

Then how does one find a representative sample and ensure getting some reasonable data to drive successful decisions? Unfortunately, there are no packaged answers. It depends on the situation.

At Prudential, where I was the head of e-Business, we used online and offline research, combined with interviews with the sales force and customer councils to get to the answer.

  • Online: We used online polls and surveys; Plurimus.com is an interesting service which gathered data from ISPs logs on what the customers surfed. They combined that with demographic and other information. Their PhDs then churned the jar to come up with models which helped determine usage by variables such as geography and demographics. This was especially useful in advertisement and new feature launches.
  • Offline: Surveys; focus groups in our specially equipped labs.
  • Customer Councils: This is especially helpful in a B2B setting. Talk to existing customer to get their ideas on what is missing and what would be good to have or add. We had councils that we met with regularly.
  • Interview the sales teams: “Who did you lose to and why” is the single most important research question one can ask. Over time a pattern develops that should tell us no survey can.

The key to effective research is not only in asking questions on customer preferences but also answering a key question: How much will you pay for this new feature or service or privilege?

Measuring Results:

“How much do you love me” is perhaps the most powerful question one can ask or respond to. My son just stretches his arms as wide and far back as he can, till he is about to tip over. Why is that immensely satisfactory yet not enough in a business situation? Perhaps, because money is riding on the answer! Perhaps, our need to quantify has stripped us of logic.

There was a time, not so long ago, when one could end up black and blue just for asking for a business case. Projects got funded and delivered (or not) without an iota of business justification. The pendulum has swung the other way completely. Now, everything is about ROI - perhaps the most flawed measure out there. For starters, one just cannot accurately quantify some things such as revenues on a new venture and allocate costs in a multi-product, multi-channel function based organization. Then there is the issue of loss leaders – “investments” one makes so our other investments make money. Ford Escort/Focus (and most small cars) is net money loser but is critical to get the young buyer who will eventually buy a Taurus which makes money or better yet an Explorer which makes more. Should a negative ROI have dissuaded Ford from building Focus?

There are many more reasons to distrust ROIs and NPVs.

Personally, I am a big proponent of metrics. I have spent a better part of my career advocating and implementing them for clients. However, I am very careful of what I quantify. There are many measures that provide the data needed to make intelligent decisions. One such measure for the web is the “click to answer” – how many clicks (or screens) did a user have to make/traverse to get to an answer they were looking for. This has a more direct correlation to customer satisfaction than the results from an online survey.

Summary:

A good marketing strategy is critical to the success of an e-Business. Marketing must be viewed as part of the overall picture, not a stand alone component. It must be tightly coupled with all other components such as strategy, processes, technology and organization. However, marketing decisions are sometimes taken in isolation. That results in “product for product’s sake”. The best hardware or software is often not the best for every situation. Much like EFT is not ideal for senior citizen and dynamic trading not applicable to retirement planning. Customer preferences should drive the marketing mix. A complete and thorough research and analysis that weighs in key factors such as product, price, promotion, place and cost should result in a marketing strategy that is the “best” one for that situation.


Related Categories




Related Topics



Related Articles


A Methodology for Developing a Portfolio of e-business Initiatives

 This paper provides a methodology to develop a portfolio of e-Business initiatives.

Best Practices in B2B Marketing

This excellent presentation discusses five best practices in business to business marketing including social media marketing.

Business Use of Web 2.0

 The paper examines the business use of web 2.0 – what is web 2.0 and what makes it different from both business and technological perspectives? What is the value proposition of web 2.0 and how businesses can best leverage it?

Compliance Management: The Business of Keeping the Business in Business

 Compliance Management: The Business of Keeping the Business in Business. Volume 4 of Digital Trust examines IT security as a technology strategy series.

Digital Marketing Strategy Guide

This excellent presentation provides in depth guidance on the critical importance of digital and social marketing, and how to create an effective digital and social marketing strategy. An excellent resource for an C-Suite executive to understand the ...

Digital Trust: Epilogue and Strategic Roadmap

 Digital Trust: Epilogue and Strategic Roadmap. Volume 8 of the Digital Trust: IT security as a Technology Strategy series.

eThreats and Countermeasures: Just When You Thought It Was Safe to Go Out

 eThreats and Countermeasures: Just When You Thought It Was Safe to Go Out. Volume 6 of Digital Trust: IT security as a Technology Strategy series.

Intellectual Property Protection: Minding Your Mind Power

Intellectual Property Protection: Minding Your Mind Power. Volume 3 of the Digital Trust examines IT security as a technology strategy series.

Liquid Security: Digital Trust When Time, Place and Platform Don't Matter

 Liquid Security: Digital Trust When Time, Place and Platform Don't Matter. Volume 5 of the Digital Trust: IT security as a Technology Strategy series.

Poster Child for Dot.com Failure

Boo.com burst into flames six months after launch but not before burning through $185M. So what happened to the promise of an exceptionally profitable website? This e_Business case study tries to find out!

Small Business e_Commerce: Handling Returns

This paper discusses the issue of ecommerce returns and how to process them.

Social Business Plan Template

This social business plan templates can be used as a framework to think about the issues in creating your social enterprise.

Social Media Planning for B2B Companies

This whitepaper aims to serve as a reference and planning tool for B2B Web 2.0/ social media initiatives by answering a simple question: How to leverage Web 2.0?

Strategies for Transitioning "Old Economy" Firms to e-Business

This paper argues that when devising an e-business strategy for legacy firms, one must be wary of the five myths of e-business development while embracing the five guidelines of managerial responsibility and leadership.

The Real Story Behind the Failure of UK eUniversity

In 2000, UK eUniversity was launched to counter the perceived threat from emerging online universities such as the University of Phoenix. By 2004, the $113M venture was on its knees. What went wrong? The author contends that the many reports publishe...

Transparency and Assurance: Putting a Measure on Digital Trust

 Transparency and Assurance: Putting a Measure on Digital Trust. Volume 7 of the Digital Trust: IT security as a Technology Strategy series.


Posted on 06/04/2009 by


eBusiness Marketing author sourabhhajela

sourabhhajela

Signup For ThoughtLeader









Subscribe


CIO Index

Our Focus is On Your Agenda

CIO Index is the world's largest professional network for CIOs - of the CIO, for the CIO, by the CIO. 

Over 70,000 CIOs and other IT Executives use CIO Index to Learn, Network and Share.

 

Cioindex, Inc.

  • (+1) 800-309-3550
  • Mon - Fri 9:00am - 5:00 pm
  • 115 Franklin Tpke, Mahwah, NJ 07430