A comparison of Enterprise Architecture Frameworks

This paper provides a framework to compare key enterprise architecture frameworks - Zachman enterprise architecture framework aka Zachman, Department of defense architecture framework aka DoDAF, Treasury enterprise architecture framework aka TEAF and, Federal enterprise architecture framework aka FEAF.

This paper provides a framework to compare key enterprise architecture frameworks - Zachman enterprise architecture framework aka Zachman, Department of defense architecture framework aka DoDAF, Treasury enterprise architecture framework aka TEAF and, Federal enterprise architecture framework aka FEAF.

I have included this paper for a few reasons other than sharing the comparison framework. The first is to highlight the state of discussion on enterprise architecture - enterprise architects are still stuck in the technology weeds - and the resulting lack of connection with business leadership. One cannot make a business case for enterprise architecture - or anything else for that matter - if we do not connect with the business aspects of it.

Take for example the definition of enterprise architecture presented in this paper: "An Enterprise Architecture Framework (EAF) maps all of the software development processes within the enterprise and how they relate and interact to fulfill the enterprise’s mission." Really?

The good news is that we are trying to make a connection to the enterprise's mission. However, is the essence of an enterprise architecture framework the mapping of software development processes? Sure, it is one of the activities but is the architecture of a house - I know there is a debate on the use of this analogy but I am trying to make a point - the mapping of all the brick, door etc. making processes?

So it turns out that the bad news is that we lose out business connection with this definition and way of thinking.

Second, I wanted to highlight the futility of comparing enterprise architecture frameworks. Again, one can admire and perhaps express a preference for the architectures of various buildings but can we truly "compare" architectures in a meaningful way? I don't believe so.

Third, the completely academic nature of these discussions - I could've said juvenile in a "my architecture is better than yours" way but I didn't go there for a reason. Enterprise architects and technology geeks like me love these kinds of discussions – sometimes it feels like we live for them! - because what meaningful discussion does one hope to make based upon such a comparison? This paper is comparing deliverables and process - does that really tell us which framework to adopt?

Download (please login and scroll down)

Download Document: Documents are in common file formats such as Microsoft Word (doc), Powerpoint (ppt), Excel (xls,csv,xlsx), and Adobe pdf.
Download


Related Categories




Related Topics



Related Articles


A Brief History of Software Architecture

This presentation provides a concise history of software architecture and discusses its future. "Software architecture is about using the power of abstraction to deal with unknowns and conquer complexity."

A Framework for Enterprise Architecture Frameworks Comparison and Selection

 This paper presents a good discussion on comparing and selecting enterprise architecture frameworks (EAF).

A Review of Enterprise Architecture Frameworks

 A systematic review of major enterprise architecture frameworks.

An Overview of Federal Enterprise Architecture (FEA)

 A quick overview of the Federal Enterprise Architecture (FEA).

Architecture and the Integrated Architecture Framework (IAF)

 This paper introduces Cap Gemini's Integrated Architecture Framework (IAF)

C4ISR Architecture Framework Evolution

 This paper presents the history, status, and plans for evolution of the C4ISR framework.

C4ISR Architecture Framework Version 2.0

C4ISR Architecture Framework history guide

Common Enterprise Architecture Frameworks

This whitepaper provides a very good overview of the common enterprise architecture frameworks. You will have to step over the vendor tool specific discussion but it is well worth the time. 

Enterprise Architecture (EA) Frameworks

This presentation provides a definition of enterprise architecture, introduces key enterprise architecture frameworks such as Zachman and discusses enterprise architecture implementation process and steps

Enterprise Architecture for Organizational Transformation

This presentation provides an overview of the Federal Enterprise Architecture Framework (FEAF) and its use in transforming government to provide value.

Enterprise Architecture Reference Models: A Shared Vision for Service-Oriented Architectures

This paper discusses how enterprise architecture (EA) reference models (RMs), when properly constructed, can provide an important governance model for managing information technology for federated operations in federated environments.

Enterprise Architecture Tool Selection Guide V5.0

EA tools abound. Do you know how to select the right one for your job? Here is a tool selection framework and guide.

Extended Enterprise Architecture Framework (E2AF)

This presentation provides an introduction to IFEAD's Extended Enterprise Architecture Framework (E2AF)

Extended Enterprise Architecture Framework (E2AF)

A one page quick reference summary of the Extended Enterprise Architecture Framework (E2AF) developed by IFEAD.

FEA Reference Models Overview 2.2

This chapter introduces the purposes and structures of the five Federal Enterprise Architecture (FEA) reference models v2.2

Federal Enterprise Architecture (FEA) - Challenges and Changes

 An overview of the Federal Enterprise Architecture (FEA) framework, its key benefits and roadmap.

Federal Enterprise Architecture Framework V1.1

This document details the Federal Enterprise Architecture Framework (FEAF) V1.1 - what is FEAF? what are its components? what is its business value?

Federal Enterprise Architecture Reference Model Maintenance Process

This paper describes a process to maintain enterprise architecture reference models. This proposed maintenance process helps revise the FEA reference models to meet requirements, as well as evolve and transform the enterprise.

Federal Enterprise Architecture Template

The purpose of this document is to provide a framework for completing the Baseline and Target Architectures for each of an organization's operating units, and provide a mechanism for “rolling up” the operating unit architectures into a single Enterp...

How is FSAM related to FEA?

This presentation provides an introduction to the Federal Enterprise Architecture (FEA), Segmented Architecture and Federal Segmented Architecture Methodology (FSAM). Then answers the question: how is FSAM related to FEA? Good discussion.

Integrated Enterprise Architecture Planning Framework

This document describes, and provides detailed guidance on implementing an integrated enterprise architecture framework that integrates key IT management disciplines to provide a holistic methodology to help technology drive business value. CIOs can ...

Integrating FEA with DoDAF and ITIL

This presentation discusses integrating the federal enterprise architecture framework with the department of defense architecture framework, information technology infrastructure library and the reference architecture for space data systems

Introduction to Business Enterprise Architecture (BEA 7.0)

Business Enterprise Architecture (BEA) is the enterprise architecture for the DoD Business Mission Area (BMA) and reflects the DoD business transformation priorities, the Business Capabilities required to support those priorities, and the combinatio...

Introduction to Enterprise Architecture Frameworks

This presentation provides a look at the history, evolution, and common components of key enterprise architecture frameworks. CIOs who want to get an idea of what EA frameworks are out there, and their basic elements will find this discussion very he...

Introduction to Methodology for Business Transformation (MBT)

 This paper describes the Methodology for Business Transformation (MBT) - a practical approach to Segment Architecture.

Introduction to the Zachman Enterprise Architecture Framework V2

This presentation provides an indepth overview of the Zachman Enterprise Architecture Framework V2 (aka Zachman Framework) and compares it to the previous version so practitioners can understand the changes, why they were made, and how to implement t...

Introduction to Zachman Framework

This presentation provides a quick introduction to the Zachman Framework for enterprise architecture planning.

Overview of the Federal Enterprise Architecture (FEA)

 Introducing the Federal Enterprise Architecture (FEA) and discussing its application, benefits and limitations.

SABSA Executive White Paper

This whitepaper presents the SABSA methodology, explains its benefits, and compares them to the classical EA methodology.

SAP Enterprise Architecture Framework

This presentation defines enterprise architecture, discusses its benefits, describes the SAP enterprise architecture framework and details its benefits over "traditional" enterprise architectures.

The Dynamic Enterprise Reference Architecture

This white paper discusses and details the considerations involved in building an architecture that will last through the years.

Treasury Enterprise Architecture Framework (TEAF)

 Treasury Enterprise Architecture Framework (TEAF) guide provides a step by step approach to creating an enterprise architecture.

Unifying Enterprise Architecture Framework

 This paper provides four perspectives on a unifying framework for the Enterprise.

Using the Federal Enterprise Architecture for Infrastructure Optimization

 This paper defines and discusses the use of the Federal Enterprise Architecture Framework for infrastructure optimization across disparate business units/organizations.

Why Doesn't the Federal Enterprise Architecture Work?

The federal government has spent more than a billion dollars in its attempt to put Enterprise Architecture into practice across the federal government. Unfortunately, much or possibly even most of this taxpayer money has been wasted. Many or likel...


Posted on 06/17/2009 by


A comparison of Enterprise Architecture Frameworks author sourabhhajela

sourabhhajela

Signup For ThoughtLeader









Subscribe


CIO Index

Our Focus is On Your Agenda

CIO Index is the world's largest professional network for CIOs - of the CIO, for the CIO, by the CIO. 

Over 70,000 CIOs and other IT Executives use CIO Index to Learn, Network and Share.

 

Cioindex, Inc.

  • (+1) 800-309-3550
  • Mon - Fri 9:00am - 5:00 pm
  • 115 Franklin Tpke, Mahwah, NJ 07430