A Framework for Assessing Enterprise Architecture (Version 2.0)

 A Framework for Assessing and Improving Enterprise Architecture Management - Version 2.0.

 Framework for Assessing and Improving Enterprise Architecture Management Version 2.0 builds on the prior version by introducing considerably more scope and content to accommodate the evolving and complex nature of EA as one of many enterprise management disciplines and the practical realities surrounding actual EA development and use. As such, this version of the framework provides a more current and pragmatic construct for viewing EA development and use. In this regard, it provides a flexible benchmark against which to plan for and measure EA program management maturity that permits thoughtful and reasonable discretion to be applied in using it. Restated, the framework is not intended to be a rigidly applied “one size fits all” checklist, but rather a flexible frame of reference that should be applied in a manner that makes sense for each organization’s unique facts and circumstances. Moreover, the framework is not intended to be viewed as the sole benchmarking tool for informing and understanding an organization’s journey toward EA maturity.

The framework consists of three interrelated components: (1) seven hierarchical stages of management maturity; (2) four representations of management attributes that are critical to the success of any program or organizational endeavor; and (3) 59 elements, or building blocks, of EA management that are at the core of an EA program. (See the figure below for a conceptual view of the framework’s components.)

Each of the seven maturity stages reflects those EA management conditions that an enterprise should meet to logically build on the capability established at the preceding stage. As such, the stages provide a road map for systematically maturing or evolving an organization’s capacity to manage an EA. The stages are: Stage 0: Creating EA Awareness; Stage 1: Establishing EA Institutional Commitment and Direction; Stage 2: Creating the Management Foundation for EA Development and Use; Stage 3: Developing Initial EA Versions; Stage 4: Completing and Using an Initial EA Version for Targeted Results; Stage 5: Expanding and Evolving the EA and Its Use for Institutional Transformation; Stage 6: Continuously Improving the EA and Its Use to Achieve Corporate Optimization.

The four critical success attribute representations provide different and complementary ways to view and thus understand the 59 core elements. The four are referred to as the (1) EA Management Action Representation, (2) EA Functional Area Representation, (3) Office of Management and Budget Capability Area Representation, and (4) EA Enabler Representation. Each provides a unique perspective on the focus and nature of the framework’s core elements.

The 59 core elements are collectively the EA practices, structures, activities, and conditions that, when properly employed based on the unique facts and circumstances of each organization and the stated purpose of its EA program, can permit that organization to progress to increasingly higher states of EA management maturity and thereby maximize its chances of realizing an EA’s institutional value.

Download (please login and scroll down)

Download Document: Documents are in common file formats such as Microsoft Word (doc), Powerpoint (ppt), Excel (xls,csv,xlsx), and Adobe pdf.

Related Categories

Related Topics

Related Articles

A Framework for Enterprise Architecture Assessment

Architecting the Enterprise for Business Value

This paper uses a case study to demonstrate the practical application of enterprise architecture to create business value. 

Case Study - Enterprise Architecture Business Value

This case study discusses ways of assessing the performance of enterprise architecture in the enterprise to measure the business results delivered. Excellent resource for the CIO who wants to ensure EA delivers value to the business.

Case Study: Enterprise Architecture Assessment

Follow this six step process to conduct an assessment of your organization's enterprise architecture. Good Read!

Creating Business Value through Enterprise Architecture

This is a global study on the business value of enterprise architecture - do business executives consider EA critical to business value? Does EA maturity level vary by organization? Is business value related to EA maturity level? How can companies i...

Delivering Flexible Business Value with Service-Oriented Architecture

This presentation provides an overview of service oriented architecture (SOA) and discusses its use to create business flexibility.

Designing an IT Architecture for the Global Enterprise

This article discusses designing an Information Technology (IT) Architecture to meet the seemingly paradoxical demands of organizational flexibility and product standardization - the former helps an organization quickly adapt to business change ther...

EA Maturity Model

Enterprise Architecture (EA) and It's Paradigm

As Enterprise Architecture (EA) function grows increasingly important, organizations need to understand that delivering highly coordinated and efficiently designed architecture structures, standards, and policies is essential to ensure success. The ...

Enterprise Architecture Assessment For Cloud Migration

This presentation discusses a migration approach to cloud computing using enterprise architecture. Good Discussion!

Enterprise Architecture Assessment Framework

This paper describes an enterprise architecture assessment framework that helps ascertain the outcome or value delivery of the EA initiative, and plan for future investment in enterprise architecture planning. The framework allows for an EA assessmen...

Enterprise Architecture Assessment Framework

This paper presents a framework to measure the value created by an enterprise architecture implementation. The focus is both on the results, and the means used to create them so corrective action can be taken. Very good discussion.

Enterprise Architecture Assessment Framework (EAAF) Guide

 Enterprise Architecture Assessment Framework (EAAF) determines the progress of an enterprise architecture program - both in terms of process and outcomes - against stated objectives.

Enterprise Architecture Assessment Framework (EAAF) Template

 Enterprise Architecture Assessment Framework (EAAF) Template determines the progress of an enterprise architecture program - both in terms of process and outcomes - against stated objectives.

Enterprise Architecture Assessment Guide

The step-by-step guide helps assess enterprise architecture using an Enterprise Architecture Score Card.

Enterprise Architecture Capability Maturity Model

Enterprise Architecture Maturity

 The architecture maturity cycle is based on the well recognized Plan-Do-Check-Act cycle, a four phase cycle for implementing change.

Enterprise Architecture Maturity and Business Process Outsourcing Success

This master thesis presents an enterprise architecture maturity framework and uses it to establish a connection between enterprise architecture maturity and business process outsourcing success.

Enterprise Architecture Maturity Assessment

 Enterprise architecture maturity assessment using an ARC-compliant approach

Enterprise Architecture Maturity Assessment

This report presents the analysis to assess enterprise architecture maturity using an enterprise architecture assessment framework. The work was done by the GAO for the federal government but can be adapted to the corporate world.

Enterprise Architecture Maturity Assessment

A simplified enterprise architecture maturity assessment model based upon a roadmap that migrates from "as-is" to "to-be" environment. Decision making at each step along the way is facilitated by understanding the risks and rewards of the options pr...

Enterprise Architecture Maturity Assessment Case Study

This case study uses Gartner's Enterprise Architecture Program Maturity Self Assessment Framework and tools to conduct a detailed assessment of the enterprise architecture program at the State of Oregon

Enterprise Architecture Maturity Dashboard

This paper discusses an approach, using standard frameworks, to assess the maturity of an organization’s Enterprise Architecture. 

Enterprise Architecture Maturity Model

This paper presents an enterprise architecture maturity model that can be used by practitioners to continually evolve their organization's enterprise architecture to adapt to changes in their internal and external environment. (400+ pages)

Enterprise Transformation Maturity Model

This paper presents a maturity model to map, and manage the enterprise transformation journey. This maturity framework connects the phases or steps in enterprise maturity with value creation thereby addressing a key gap in existing maturity models su...

Extended Enterprise Architecture Maturity Model (E2AMM) 2.0

 Quick reference guide to Extended Enterprise Architecture Maturity Model (E2AMM) 2.0 developed by IFEAD.

How can Enterprise Architecture Help Lower IT Costs?

This presentation discusses using enterprise architecture planning to lower IT costs and increase business benefits. Excellent discussion!

How Does Enterprise Architecture Add Value

This paper makes a business case for enterprise architecture - the authors present an EA Benefits Model (EABM) which proposes that "EA leads to organisational benefits through its impact on four key benefit enablers: Organisational Alignment, Inform...

Improving Enterprise Architecture Use

Are we there yet? Use this EA Maturity and Assessment guide to take your organization's EA to its destination.

IT Architecture Capability Maturity Model

This paper introduces an IT Architecture Capability Maturity Model (CMM) which provides a framework of key components of an effective IT Architecture process. This CMM presents an evolutionary model to improve IT Architecture process that starts out ...

IT Architecture Capability Maturity Model Guide

This IT architecture capability maturity model (CMM) assessment guide explains a framework to assess the progress an organization has made in implementing enterprise architecture against established best practices targets – the underlying premise is...

IT Architecture Capability Maturity Model Template

This IT architecture capability maturity model (CMM) assessment guide explains a framework to assess the progress an organization has made in implementing enterprise architecture against established best practices targets – the underlying premise is...

Maximizing Your SOA Investment

This paper discusses the business case for the service oriented architecture (SOA) investment - "it provides the dynamic capability to create innovation for managing change and empowering competitive advantage."

SAP Enterprise Architecture Framework

This presentation defines enterprise architecture, discusses its benefits, describes the SAP enterprise architecture framework and details its benefits over "traditional" enterprise architectures.

The Dynamic Enterprise Reference Architecture

This white paper discusses and details the considerations involved in building an architecture that will last through the years.

TOGAF Capability Maturity Model

This in depth guide and template provides a practical framework for maturity assessment of TOGAF based enterprise architecture implementations. IT Architecture capability maturity assessment identifies gaps between "to-be" vision and "as-is" capabili...

What is Wrong with Enterprise Architecture?

This paper discusses, in-depth, the root causes for the failure of enterprise architecture planning in organizations. CIOs must read this to understand why their EA initiative is likely to fail if it has not already. Enterprise Architects need to re...

Posted on 03/01/2011 by

A Framework for Assessing Enterprise Architecture (Version 2.0) author Webmaster1



For ThoughtLeader

CIO Index

Our Focus is On Your Agenda

CIO Index is the world's largest professional network for CIOs - of the CIO, for the CIO, by the CIO. 

Over 75,000 CIOs and other IT Executives use CIO Index to Learn, Network and Share.


Cioindex, Inc.

  • (+1) 800-309-3550
  • Mon - Fri 9:00am - 5:00 pm
  • 375 North Stephanie St., Ste 1411, Henderson, NV 89014